|
Stafford Methodist Church, 218
W Stafford
Description
Exterior
The First Methodist Episcopal Church is located at 218 West Stafford
Street in Stafford, Kansas, two blocks from the main street of downtown Stafford
and in a residential neighborhood of Revival style houses such as Dutch and
Tudor Revival along with ranch style residences. The church was designed by Don
Buel Schuler (1888-1972) of Schuler and Company of Wichita, Kansas. The corner
stone of the church was laid on September 6, 1925, the basement was completed in
the fall of 1926, and the church was dedicated on May 22, 1927 (Plate 1). The two-story church with a full
basement, is a brown brick building with running bond and flush mortar joints,
limestone trim and a concrete foundation supported by twenty-nine concrete
footings. The church is almost square, being slightly longer than it is wide and
is an auditorium-type church.
The First Methodist Episcopal Church is one of the most extraordinary
churches in the state of Kansas. The church differs architecturally from all
Stafford's other churches built in the conventional Gothic Revival style. Its
exterior is an interpretation in a stream-lined form of the English Collegiate
Gothic and on its interior in the sanctuary an imaginative interpretation of the
Prairie School deriving from Frank Lloyd Wright's Unity Temple in Oak Park,
Illinois (1905-1909). Indeed, viewing the exterior, one would think it is a
secular rather than an ecclesiastical building, perhaps, a school auditorium or
gymnasium. The church's exterior bears a strong allegiance to the English
Collegiate Gothic high school of 1916 less than a block away within view from
the church. Nor does the exterior of the church give any hint of the unusual
nature of its sanctuary in the interior.
The south, front, elevation has a ground floor of two bays with double
casement windows flanking the staircase and a door on the east side of the
staircase leading to the basement. A wide limestone string course that wraps
around the building divides the ground floor from the first floor (Plate 2).
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____7___ Page____2___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
The first floor of the church is reached by a staircase with eighteen
steps, and a landing and is flanked by brick parapets capped with limestone
blocks.
Five bays define the first floor, three entrance doors flanked by
casement windows with opaque milky yellow and white glazing. The three-bay
central section is slightly projecting and consists of three portals which is
typical of European ecclesiastical architecture. Flanking the three entrances
are large brick stepped-wall buttresses capped with pointed limestone finials
that
define the first and second stories and continue upward, breaking
through the roof line. Each entrance has double doors with a transom above it.
Above each transom is a limestone frieze decorated with four discs in relief
followed by a limestone string course that wraps around the building and
separates the first from the second story. As indicated in the blue print of the
front elevation, Schuler intended to have eight small lancet windows in place of
the three over five clear glass transoms, which would have added a High Gothic
character to the front elevation.
The second story consists of five bays of five windows sitting on a
limestone string course that wraps around the building. The three-bay central
section consists of triple casement windows with opaque milky yellow and white
glazing. Between the doors are the stepped wall buttresses raising from the
first floor and continuing upward through the roof line. Flanking the central
section are double casement windows with the same opaque glazing as elsewhere on
the elevation. Above is a limestone disc frieze over each door followed by
several brick courses and then the roof line (Plate 3).
As originally designed and built, the pyramidal roof was slightly upward
thrusting with a skylight in the center to illuminate the thirty-six stained
glass panels in the ceiling of the sanctuary. In 1955, the original roof was
removed and a new one installed and the skylight closed because it leaked.
The
east and west elevations are virtually the same except for a brick chimney on the east elevation and
the slightly different fenestration pattern of
the two elevations. The east elevation has an eight-bay basement of
double casement windows except for the second window from the southeast corner
which is a single casement window. The central section of six bays projects
slightly from the elevation. A brick chimney is located between the
next to the last and the last window at the northeast corner and continues
through all
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____7___ Page____3___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
three stories, rising above the roof line. The broad limestone
string course
that wraps around the building divides the basement from the first
floor, which like the basement slightly projects from the elevation.
The first story consists of thirteen bays with two pairs of double hung
casement windows with opaque milky yellow and white glazing flanking the nine
bay projecting central section which consists of double casement windows with
the same opaque glazing. Eight of the casement windows, which are slightly off
center, sit on a limestone string course and illuminate the side rooms flanking
the sanctuary. A disc frieze terminates the projecting central section and above
it a limestone string course separates the first from the second floor.
The second story of fourteen windows sits on the limestone string course
separating the first and second stories. The ten-bay central section has single
casement windows with opaque milky yellow and white glazing and is flanked by
double casement windows on either side with the same glazing. A single casement
window with opaque glazing abuts the brick chimney on the north followed by a
double casement window with opaque glass at the northeast corner. All the
windows except for the two next to the northeast corner illuminate the balcony
area of the sanctuary. Terminating the second story is the disc frieze followed
by several brick courses then the roof line (Plate 4).
The west elevation is virtually identical to the east elevation but is without a brick chimney and has nine
windows in the basement instead of the eight that define east elevation's
basement (Plate 5).
The north, rear, elevation has been altered slightly and consists of a
basement story of six bays with two doors at each side that break through the limestone string course. Between the
doors are four double casement windows with clear glazing. A broad limestone
string course separates the basement
from the first story. Originally, the first story consisted of
seven double casement windows with milky yellow and white glazing. The second
and sixth windows are situated well above the other windows in order to
illuminate the stairs to the organ loft. The only alteration to the elevation is
the replacement of the third window at the northeast corner with a door. A
limestone string
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____7___ Page____4___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
course separates the first from the second floor that is without
any
fenestration and is terminated by the disc frieze followed by brick
courses then the roof line (Plate 6).
Interiors
One enters the church through one of three doors into the vestibule or
narthex of the church. Sun light from the three doors and the transoms
illuminates the vestibule that acts as a transitional area between the exterior,
secular world and the interior, ecclesiastical world of the church's sanctuary.
The only association with the sanctuary is the four pyramidal stained glass
light lamps hanging from the vestibule's ceiling. These pyramid lamps with
their yellow stained glazing with colorful chevron patterns defining the
mid-section of each of the four sides of the pyramid, are repeated in a larger
version on the sanctuary ceiling (Plate 7).
Flanking the sanctuary to the east are a series of six rooms beginning
with a meeting room with a restroom followed by classrooms and a chapel. To the
west are six rooms. The pastor's office and next to it is the secretary's
office followed by classrooms and meeting rooms. Straight ahead up four steps is
the sanctuary of the church that is a world apart from the transitional
vestibule and the secular world outside the church.
Upon entering the sanctuary of the First Methodist Episcopal Church, one
is in the worship space sealed-off from the outside world as well as from the
rest of the church. A central aisle flanked by twelve rows of the original
walnut pews leads to the raised chancel with an organ console to the left
followed by a lectern, a communion table in the center, another lectern and a
piano. Behind the communion table is a raised area for the choir and behind it
walnut paneling and above the walnut organ screen that runs the full length of
the chancel. Schuler designed the walnut paneling and organ screen and in 1931,
the church installed a Molar organ, which parishioners claim is the only pipe
organ between Hutchinson and Dodge City.
Balconies occupy the side and the rear of the sanctuary and are reached by stairs flanking the chancel and
in the corners at the rear of the sanctuary.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____7___ Page____5___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Originally, Schuler's plan called for the rear balcony to be used
as the assembly
room for the junior department of the Sunday school and, if needed,
as additional seating for the sanctuary. At the northeast and northwest corners
of the balcony are three classrooms and stairs leading to the sanctuary and
basement. The ceiling and the walls of the sanctuary are rendered in off-white
plaster. Pairs of walnut bands, which have a elastic sense to them and are
continuous and flowing, spring from a single walnut band located above the
balcony windows, and demarcate the balconies, chancel and choir and lead the eye
from one surface to another.
The most extraordinary aspect of the sanctuary is its lighting. Arrayed
across the sanctuary's ceiling in six rows of six are thirty-six
stained-glass
boxes termed "sunlight glass"
for the predominate yellow color that dominates
each glass box. Each box has wood strips that divide and subdivide
each
square with small green stained-glass squares in the inner and
outer corners of
each square. Originally, each box was illuminated by a skylight
situated in the middle of the roof. In 1955, the old roof was removed and a new
one installed. At the same time, the skylight, which had leaked for years, was
removed, a roof
put in its place, and an
electric light bulb was inserted in each box to provide
illumination. This alteration has enriched the quality of the
"sunlight" emanating from the thirty-six stained-glass boxes, providing a
steady stream of light during the day as well as in the evening (Plate 8).
Hanging from the four corners of the ceiling are stained-glass pyramid
lamps with yellow stained glass and green, red and yellow chevrons down the
center of each of the four sides in the same manner as the pyramidal
stained-glass lamps hanging from the vestibule's ceiling (Plate 9). The
clerestory windows above the side and rear balconies have opaque milky yellow
and white stained glass that further enhances the "sunlight" effect in the
sanctuary. Three box lights also with the same glazing are located in the three
balconies and another five box lights with the same stained glass illuminate the
chancel and choir.
All the light in the sanctuary, except for the minimal amount of natural
light issuing from the three entrance doors and their transoms, is yellow in
color. Light has always been a symbol of God in Christian churches. The flood
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____7___ Page____6___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
of yellow light in the sanctuary glorifying the sun serves to
emphasize the
distinction between the exterior of the church with its secular
English Collegiate Gothic front elevation and the sanctuary and heightens the
parishioners awareness of being in a sacred space.
The church has a full basement consisting of a large fellowship hall in
the center of the basement which is entered by stairs from the vestibule and
through the lobby. Flanking the lobby is a nursery and large classroom and a
flight of stairs leading to the outside. To the east of the fellowship hall is a
large kitchen with a janitor's closet, a furnace room and classrooms and in the
northeast corner a flight of stairs leading to a rear door, the sanctuary and
the balcony area. On the other side of the fellowship hall are three classrooms,
two smaller rooms and stairs leading to the sanctuary and the balcony.
Architectural Integrity and Condition
The condition of the First
Methodist Episcopal Church is exemplary. The parishioners are proud of their
church and have had an annual maintenance program since the church was erected.
The church has retained its architectural integrity even though there have been
three alterations to the fabric of the church. Two of the three alterations have
been cited, the removal of the the skylight over the sanctuary and the insertion
of a door in the place of a window on the second story of the rear elevation.
The third alteration occurred in 2001, when clear-glass storm windows were
inserted on the interior of the clerestory windows to prevent a loss of heating
and cooling.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____1___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Historical Development
The First Methodist Episcopal Church located at 219 West Stafford, in
Stafford, Kansas qualifies for the National Register of Historic Places
nomination under Criterion C, because it presents an imaginative interpretation
of a Prairie style church with its stream-lined English Collegiate Gothic
exterior and its sanctuary inspired by Frank Lloyd Wright's Unity Temple
sanctuary.
The Gothic Revival style had its origins in Great Britain and took hold
on the eastern seaboard of this country. Initially, the style was used for
public buildings by such notable early American architects as Benjamin Latrobe
in his Bank of American of 1807 and William Strickland in his Masonic Hall of
1808, both in Philadelphia. Although the Gothic Revival style was also used for
commercial and domestic buildings, it found its greatest expression in
ecclesiastical architecture.
The English Collegiate Gothic style is a secular variation of the Gothic
Revival and was based upon the Gothic buildings at Cambridge and Oxford
University. Originally, the term had several variations and probably originated
with the architect Alexander Jackson Davis (1803-1892). In Davis's office diary
for 1845-1846, he refers to domestic designs as "Collegiate style,"
"Collegiate Gothic Villa style," and "English Collegiate style."
Davis was among the pioneers who used the English Collegiate Gothic style on
college campuses and was the first to design an entire campus in that style at
the Virginia Military Institute (1848-1850) in Lexington, Virginia. Throughout
the nineteenth century, it was understood that the term Collegiate Gothic
referred to English academic architecture and not to any other European
country's architecture.
In all probability, it was the architect Ralph Adams Cram (1863-1942), an
outspoken advocate of the Gothic style, who was responsible for adding Gothic to
the term "English Collegiate style." Cram designed a number of buildings on
college and university campuses in the English Collegiate Gothic style. The
English Collegiate Gothic style partook of the same characteristics
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____2___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
as the Gothic revival. In varying degrees English Collegiate Gothic
buildings are characterized by pointed Gothic arches, stained glass, lancet
windows, wall and flying buttresses, fortress towers, crenellation, battered
walls and ribbed vaulting. The main building materials of the style were stone,
as exemplified by
the numerous English Collegiate Gothic buildings on the Yale campus
by
James Gamble Rogers (1917-1921 & 1927) and brick with stone trim,
as exemplified by the University of Richmond (1910-1914), whose campus plan was
designed by Cram and who also designed many of the school's buildings. In the
Midwest and especially in Kansas, brick with limestone trim was the prevalent
building material, as it is for the First Methodist Episcopal Church.
The exterior of the Stafford church is defined by its English Collegiate
Gothic front elevation. The salient English Collegiate Gothic feature setting
the tone for the church's exterior is the four stepped-wall buttresses that
flank and alternate with the three entrance doors. The other Gothic feature is a
frieze decorated with disks located above each of the three entrance doors and a
second frieze just below the roof line that wraps around the building (Plate 3).
According to Schuler's design, the front elevation was to have a set of eight
small lancet windows above each of the three entrance doors, instead of the
transoms present on the front elevation. Had the building committee followed
Schuler's design, the three sets of lancet windows would have added a High
Gothic character to the front elevation.
The defining characteristic of the Stafford's Methodist church is its
sanctuary which is in the form of an auditorium. Auditorium-type churches were
radically removed from the traditional basilican churches with their linear
progression from nave and side aisles to transepts, altar and apse. Of course,
the auditorium-style church has a long lineage beginning with the Early
Christian church in the round, which became a fixation of Italian Renaissance
architects.
With the Reformation and the rise of Protestant denominations the
transformation of the basilican church occurred. In the Protestant
church the sermon and its audibility were of paramount importance, and the
congregation
became an active participant in the service, partaking in the
liturgy and the Communion. The Protestant worship space known as the "temple
protestant"
became in America the meeting
house and later the auditorium-style church
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____3___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
popular with the Unitarians, the Christian Science church and other
denominations in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
By far the most extraordinary feature of the First Methodist Episcopal
Church is the sanctuary's ceiling lighting. Arrayed across the ceiling in six
rows of six are thirty-six stained glass boxes termed "sunlight glass" for the
predominate yellow color issuing from them. Each box has wood strips that divide
and subdivide each square with small green stained-glass squares in the inner
and outer corners of each square. Each glass box was illuminated by a skylight
situated in the middle of the roof. Hanging from the four corners of the ceiling
are pyramidal yellow stained-glass lamps with colorful chevrons down the center
of each of the four sides of the pyramid.
In 1955, when a new roof was installed, the skylight was closed because
it constantly leaked. In place of the natural light from the skylight, a light
bulb was inserted in each light box to provide illumination. This alteration to
Schuler's plan has enriched the quality of the "sunlight" issuing from the glass boxes,
providing a steady stream of light during the day as well as in the evening.
"Light screen," the term Wright used to describe his stained glass
windows, was an integral part of his architecture from 1886 through
the 1920s. Wright used light to great effect to
illuminate and define space and to integrate nature with the interiors of his
residences, or as Wright declared, light allows the inhabitant to commune with
nature without being buffeted by it. His Prairie School residences are filled
with light screens composed of abstract patterns with muted colors taken from
nature and set in casement sashes.
Wright also employed his light screens as skylights in many of his
residences, inserting them in barrel vaulted and flat ceilings. An early example
of such treatment are the barrel vaulted ceiling in the playroom of his Oak Park
home (1895) and the flat ceiling of his Oak Park studio (1898-1900). Another
spectacular light-filled barrel vaulted ceiling is the one in the living room
ceiling of the second Francis W. Little residence (1912-1914), now in the
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____4___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Metropolitan Museum of Art. Light screen panels are also found in
many of Wright's dining room ceilings, such as the Tomek residence (1901-1906)
and
the Allen House (1916-1917), his last Prairie School residence. In
each dining room the length of the light screen panel was determined by the
length of the dining room table also designed by Wright. But his most
magnificent use of skylights is the sanctuary ceiling of Unity Temple
(1905-1908).
Without light filtered through the clerestory windows and the skylight
boxes in the ceiling, Unity Temple's sanctuary would be a dead space. According
to Wright, the ceiling became sunlight with the twenty-five ceiling boxes
filtering the light through amber light screens so that: "Thus managed the
light would, rain or shine, have the warmth of sunlight."
Schuler certainly understood Wright's concept that "light is the
beautifier of the building."
Following his example, Schuler bathed the sanctuary of the Stafford church in a
warm yellow light in imitation of sunlight and as a reference to Jesus as the
Light of the World, or as Wright stated: "by way of glass the sunlit space as a
reality becomes [a] most useful
servant of a higher order of the human Spirit."
The present church is the third building to be erected on the site. After
many years of holding services in private homes, the second floor of a
commercial building on Stafford's Main Street and in Stafford's first school
house, a church was erected in 1883. This church was a modest frame structure in
the Gothic Revival style, with pointed Gothic windows, and at the corner was the
entrance and a tall bell tower surmounted by a spire. By the beginning of the
twentieth century the modest frame church could not
accommodate the growing parish. In 1905, the old frame church was
placed to one side and a new Gothic style brick church erected in its place. The
new church was L-shaped with pointed Gothic windows and a tall bell tower
located at the juncture of the L and punctuated by pointed Gothic windows.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-00
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____5___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
By 1915, the second church was too small for its growing congregation
and during the war years the walls of the church were badly
cracked.
Contractors advised that it would be more practical and economical
to raze the church. Following the contractors recommendations, the parishioners
decided to proceed with the design and building of a third church. A building
committee was formed and they studied church design, structure and material. The
committee then visited many new churches in Stafford and in south-central Kansas
before selecting as their model the
Riverside Christian Church in the Riverside neighborhood of Wichita, Kansas.
The Riverside Church of Christ was organized in 1921 and a year later
construction of a new church began. By April 1922, the church was completed
at a cost of $45,000.00. The
architect was Don Schuler of Wichita. An article in the Wichita Eagle
newspaper described Schuler's church as "one of the most beautiful and
distinctive in Wichita. The architectural design is different from
any other church in the city and is creating very favorable
comment."
We do not know what prompted the First Methodist Episcopal Church's
building committee to select a church style in direct contrast to
the medieval
church tradition that prevailed in this country and that was
certainly at variance with Stafford's two Gothic Revival style churches that
preceded it. By any standard, it was a bold choice for a church building
committee from a small town on the Kansas prairie to make. Good design has an
innate appeal that can dissolve traditional tastes and ingrained cultural
habits. But, in all likelihood, the building committee was probably enthralled
with the sanctuary of the Riverside Church of Christ, although they were
probably not aware of the background of the architect, Don Schuler. A comment in
the Wichita Eagle at the time of the church's dedication captures the
appeal that the church's sanctuary probably had for Stafford's building
committee. "One of the unique things about the building is the "sunlight
glass." There is a skylight above the
main auditorium containing 36 separate glasses with an electric
light bulb over
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-001
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____6___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
each. At night, with the electric lights turned on, there is the
same effect as in
the daytime, giving a constant daylight effect. This feature is
said to be the
only one in a church in this section of the country." But the three men who comprised the church's
building committee were not without their detractors. "These men, of course,
took much criticism because it was impossible to please the entire
congregation."
Don Schuler of Schuler Company of Wichita came to Stafford and helped
make the final plans. The total cost of the church was approximately $30,000 of
which $18, 940 had been raised through subscriptions by 1923. Although Schuler
provided the design for the new church, he was not employed to oversee the
church's construction. This was done by the church building committee. The
committee hired the local H. C. McCurdy Lumber Company as
purchasing agent and local contractors were hired to build the
church.
The
Depression, Dust Bowl and Second World War
hindered the rapid payment of the church's construction debt. But by 1944, the
final debt payment was made and on February 27, 1944, a mortgage burning
ceremony was held to celebrate
the termination of the church's indebtedness.
Until 1990 when the Allen-Lambe Foundation acquired Frank Lloyd Wright's
Allen House from Wichita State University, Don Buel Schuler (1888-1972) and his
architectural career in Wichita had been forgotten. With the discovery that he
was Wright's site architect for the building of the Allen House (1917-1918), he
and his architectural accomplishments in Wichita have been rescued from
oblivion.
Don Buel Schuler was born in Englewood, Kansas in 1888, and came to
Wichita with his family at early age (Plate 10). His father Buel M. Schuler was
a successful building contractor in Wichita and was joined by his three
children, Don, Mildred and Ivan in the business. Don as well as his sister and
brother all graduated from Farirmount College (now Wichita State University). He
graduated with honors in chemistry and Cum Laude with a major in
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-001
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____7___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Mathematics-Physical in 1911.
After graduation, Schuler worked in the Kansas City, Missouri Engineer Office
designing sewer pipe. In the autumn of
1913, he enrolled at the University of Illinois at Champaign-Urbana
where he
received a Bachelor of Science in Architectural Engineering in
June, 1916.
While studying for his architecture degree, Schuler spent his summers in
the Chicago architectural office of Francis Berry Byrne (1883-1967).
Byrne received his training as an architectural apprentice in Frank Lloyd
Wright's Oak Park studio, turning rough preliminary designs into working
drawings. One of the projects that he worked on was Wright's design for Unity
Temple, before leaving Wright's
studio to start his own career in 1908.
In 1914, Byrne assumed responsibility for managing the Chicago office of
Walter Burley Griffin, another of Wright's Oak Park studio protŽgŽs. It was
there in the summer of 1915 that Schuler was working when Wright visited the
office looking for a draftsman to work on the designs for the Wichita residence
of Elsie N. and Henry J. Allen. According to Schuler's sister, Mildred, Wright
hired Schuler. In the winter of 1916, Schuler took the train to Spring Green
and entered the office of Frank Lloyd Wright to work on the Allen
House
design. From
Spring Green he was sent to Wichita as Wright's site architect
to oversee the construction of the Allen House.
After completion of the Allen House, Schuler had an architectural
practice in Wichita for ten years. After a prosperous career in Wichita, he moved his family in 1926 to Mobile,
Alabama where he worked for seven years in the office of George B. Rogers. In
1933 Schuler moved again, this time to Tuscaloosa, Alabama, so his three
daughters could attend the University of Alabama. For the first two years in
Tuscaloosa, he worked as an Engineer Inspector for the Public Works
Administration, and for the next seventeen years, he had a very lucrative
architectural practice, designing churches,
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-001
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____8___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
schools, his own and other residences, as well as commercial
buildings.
Schuler's ten years in Wichita were very fruitful for him. He
designed four residences all of which, with one exception, were done in the
Prairie style:
his own residence of 1919 in the Fairmont neighborhood of Fairmount
College (demolished in 1993); and three residences in the developing College
Hill neighborhood. The Gill residence, built in 1922 on the foundations of an
old farm house, is located at Bluff and Second Street, a few blocks from the
Allen House to which it is stylistically indebted; the residence at 4023 East
Waterman located on the southern edge of College Hill; and the American Colonial
residence of M. C. and Gwendolyn H. Naftzger of 1917. In addition, Schuler
designed three commercial buildings in downtown Wichita, none of which bore any
allegiance to the Prairie style. He reserved his most imaginative work for the
five churches he designed, three in Wichita which have been demolished, one in
Augusta, now owned by the Church of the Nazarene, which retained Schuler's Art
deco exteriors, but destroyed his sanctuary, and one in Stafford, Kansas. Of
these churches, three of them in Augusta, Wichita, and Stafford were
auditorium-style churches with sanctuaries patterned after the sanctuary of
Wright's Unity Temple. The most unusual of all Schuler's design and the one
that was ephemeral in nature is the Victory Arch made of wood with a white
stucco finish and a span of seventy feet and a height of forty feet. It was
located at Broadway and Douglas in the heart of downtown Wichita, and on May May
9, 1919, Wichita's returning World War One soldiers paraded under the arch to a
cheering crowd of 105,000.
The three auditorium-style churches Schuler designed were erected within
a three year period of each other from the early to mid-1920's. The Riverside
Church of Christ was the first to be erected in 1922. Augusta's First Methodist
Episcopal Church followed in 1924 and a year later the corner stone of the First
Methodist Episcopal Church was laid in 1925. The only church that did not have a
Prairie style exterior was the Augusta First Methodist Episcopal Church which
has a lavish Art Deco exterior. But all three sanctuaries were patterned after
the sanctuary of Wright's Unity Temple and were dominated by light emanating
from thirty-six "sunlight glass" boxes in the
sanctuary's ceiling.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-001
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____8___ Page____9___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Schuler certainly would have known and seen Wright's Unity Temple.
The
church was and is still considered to be one of his masterpieces
and an icon among metropolitan Chicago churches. Furthermore, Barry Byrne, who
employed Schuler during the summers while he attended the University of
Illinois, worked on the Unity Temple drawings while in Wright's Oak Park
studio.
Although Schuler's design for
the exterior of the Stafford church was in the Prairie style, like the Riverside
Church of Christ, the Stafford building committee did not slavishly follow its
model. They departed from it radically on the exterior of the church, replacing
the Prairie style front elevation with an English Collegiate Gothic elevation
and on the side and rear elevations, replacing the Prairie style with a modified
English Collegiate Gothic style (Plates 11 & 12). By contrast, the committee
followed Schuler's design for the
interior and in particular for the sanctuary that was a copy of the
Riverside
Church of Christ's sanctuary.
Of course, both of the church interiors were
patterned after the sanctuary of Wright's Unity Temple with two
basic
differences. Wright's sanctuary had twenty-five stained glass
boxes and a
double balcony on the rear and side elevations whereas in the
Stafford
church there were thirty-six stained glass boxes and one balcony at
the rear and side elevations (Plate 13).
But these are inconsequential differences. For Schuler has captured the
essence of Wright's Unity Temple sanctuary in the First Methodist Episcopal
Church. Furthermore, the church stands as a worthy representative and reminder
of the Riverside Church of Christ that was demolished in 1965.
The First Methodist Episcopal Church is an extraordinary edifice sitting
in the middle Kansas prairie. Beloved by generations of its parishioners and in
excellent condition, the church will be a worthy addition to Kansas's
architectural heritage and to that of the nation.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____9__ Page____1___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Bibliography
Documents
Author's Interview with Mildred Schuler.
[Correspondence of Frank Lloyd Wright]. The Frank Lloyd Wright
Archives, Taliesin West, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Student Records Office, Wichita State University, Wichita, Kansas.
Transcript Department, University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana,
Illinois.
Warranty Deed, August 29, 1883, Stafford County, Kansas.
Pamphlet, First Methodist Episcopal Church, Augusta, Kansas.
Pamphlet, Riverside Church of Christ, November, 1922, Wichita,
Kansas.
Pamphlet, First Methodist Episcopal Church, February 27, 1944.
General Works
Brooks, H. Allen, The Prairie School: Frank Lloyd Wright and His
Midwest Contemporaries. 1972: paperback reprint, New York: W. W. Norton &
Company, 1976.
,
History of
the First Methodist Church of Stafford, Kansas: From Its Beginning to May, 1965.
Sloan, Julie L. Light Screens: The Complete Leaded-Glass Windows
of Frank Lloyd Wright. New York: Rizzoli International Publications, Inc.,
2001.
Siry, Joseph M. Unity Temple: Frank Lloyd Wright and
Architecture for Liberal Religion. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University
Press, 1996.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____9__ Page____2___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Turner, Paul Venable. Campus: An American Planning Tradition.
Cambridge, Massachusets, 1984.
Wright, Frank Lloyd. An Autobiography. 1932. rev. ed., New
York: Horizon Press, 1977.
Wright, Frank Lloyd. Essays by Frank Lloyd Wright for
Architectural Record 1908-1952. reprint ed., New York: Architectural Record
Books, 1975.
Newspaper Articles
Tuscaloosa News: 29 December 1991; 17 July 1994.
Wichita Beacon: 7 January 1919; 8 May 1919.
Wichita Eagle: 28 July 1922; 29 April,1923; 3
February 1994; 23 February 1995; 3 June 1999.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____10___ Page____1___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Verbal Boundary Description
The First Methodist Episcopal Church occupies lots twenty (20),
twenty-one (21) and twenty-two (22) in the Baumgartner Addition in Stafford,
Kansas. The property is bounded on the south by West Stafford Street, on the
north by Chestnut Street, on the east by Union Street and on the west by Park
Street.
Boundary Justification
The boundary contains all property historically associated with the First
Methodist Episcopal Church in Stafford, Kansas.
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____11___ Page____1___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Photographs
Plate 1.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Original Negative: Pamela D.
Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Corner stone of
the church looking southwest
Plate 2.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Original Negative: Pamela D.
Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: South, front
elevation of the church
Plate 3.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Original Negative: Pamela D.
Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Close-up view of
the south, front elevation of the church
Plate 4.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Original Negative: Pamela D.
Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: East elevation of
the church
Plate 5.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Original Negative: Pamela D.
Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: West elevation of
the church
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____11___ Page____2___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Plate 6.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: North elevation of
the church
Plate 7.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Vestibule ceiling
looking southeast
Plate 8.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Chancel and the
sanctuary ceiling looking north
Plate 9.
Photographer: Pamela D. Kingsbury
Date of Photograph: January 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: East balcony and
sanctuary ceiling
Plate 10.
Photographer: Douglas Black & White
Photographic Imaging
Date of Photograph: March 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Portrait of Don
Buel Schuler
Plate 11.
Photographer: Douglas Black & White
Photographic Imaging
Date of Photograph: March 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Presentation
drawing of the Riverside Church of Christ looking northwest
NPS Form 10-900-a
OMB Approval No. 1024-0018
(8-86)
United States
Department of the Interior
National Park Service
NATIONAL
REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES
CONTINUATION SHEET
Section
Number____11___ Page____3___
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
Plate 12.
Photographer: Douglas Black & White
Photographic Imaging
Date of Photograph: March 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: Presentation
drawing of the First Methodist Episcopal Church looking southwest
Plate 13.
Photographer: Douglas Black & White
Photographic Imaging
Date of Photograph: March 2002
Location of Negative: Pamela D. Kingsbury
View and Its Direction: View of the
sanctuary of Unity Temple looking east
n. a., History of The First Methodist Church of
Stafford, Kansas: From It's
(sic) Beginning to May, 1965, n. p., n. d., pp. 4-5.
n. a., History of the First Methodist Church,
Stafford, Kansas, p. 6
Wichita Eagle, April 29, 1923, p.12
Paul Venable Turner, Campus: An American Planning
Tradition (Cambridge, Massachusetts:
MIT Press, 1984), p.124, p. 317.
Julie L. Sloan, Light Screens: The Complete
Leaded-Glass Windows of Frank Lloyd Wright. ( New York: Rizzoli
International Publications, Inc., 2001),
pp. 29-33.
Frank Lloyd Wright, An Autobiography. 1932.
(Reprint, New York: Horizon Press, 1977), p. 180.
Sloan, Light Screens, p. 41.
n. a., History of the First Methodist Church of
Stafford, Kansas, pp. 2-4.
Ibid., p.5.
In the history of the Stafford Methodist Church the Riverside Church of Christ
is incorrectly titled the Riverside Christian Church.
n. a., Riverside Church of Christ, November, 1922
The church was demolished in 1965, because the
congregation chose to have a new church on the site rather than deal with the
problem of access for the handicapped
Wichita Eagle, April 29, 1923, p. 12.
n. a.,History of the First Methodist Church of
Stafford, Kansas, p. 5.
Student Records office, Wichita State University,
Wichita, Kansas.
Transcript Department, University of Illinois,
Champaigne-Urbana, Illinois.
Author's interview with Mildred Schuler, 2 May 1993.
H. Allen Brooks, The Prairie School: Frank Lloyd
Wright and His Midwest Contemporaries (New York: W. W. Norton & Company,
1976), pp. 284-285.
Author's interview with Mildred Schuler, 2 May 1993.
Don Schuler, Wichita, Kansas to Frank Lloyd Wright, 8 March 1916, SOO5D09
[Correspondence of Frank Lloyd Wright], The Frank Lloyd Wright Archives,
Taliesin West, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Gene Ford, The Tuscaloosa News, 17 July 1994, p.4
F.
Wichita Beacon , 7 January 1919, p 4 & 8 May 1919, p.1. Beccy Tanner,Wichita
Eagle, 3 February 1994, n. p.
|